Book Review The Lies of Locke Lamora  | Scott Lynch

Introduction

The Lies of Locke Lamora stayed on my virtual and physical shelves for many years. It was always sitting on my long TBR. In fact, whenever people talk about fantasy, this book often shows up in conversations about the best fantasy books. It continues to appear in different lists again and again. Eventually, after so much time, I finally decided to read it and form my own opinion about why it stands out.

Plot

The plot shows the rise of Locke Lamora through two stories told side by side. At first, as a young boy, he joins a guild and grows up under his master. Meanwhile, in the current timeline, he becomes established and leads daring heists. Eventually, both threads slowly build toward one large heist at the end. These stories reveal his skills as a thief, his relationships, and the life lessons that help him survive in the thieves guild.

The novel is grimdark fantasy with dark jokes, gruesome moments, and humor that never takes itself too seriously. It gives the reader both tension and genuine laughs. This blend is rare in fantasy, though more common in grimdark stories, which makes it a favourite read.

However, at first, the plot may feel disjointed as Lamora, now older, struggles to find his footing. Once the direction becomes clear, the intrigue grows fast.

Premise & Main Character in The Lies of Locke Lamora

The Lies of Locke Lamora feels like Oliver Twist blended with Once Upon a Time in America. The focus is on an Artful Dodger–type hero. The story has fun, sharp dynamics, layered characters, ingenious plots, and a dislikable villain who keeps the tension high. It is no surprise that it appears in many lists of the best fantasy books. Overall, for me, the time spent reading it was absolutely worth it.

Locke Lamora is an infamous trickster who plays dangerous games against gods and men. A shadow of a big death always hangs over him, with knives, hot irons, and fifty thousand cheering spectators haunting the backdrop. As the leader of the Gentleman Bastards, his name suits his daring nature. From there, he carved out a risky living by stealing from the dull who could not prevent it. His story is one long, dangerous hustle, and that is exactly what makes him unforgettable.

Writing Style & Prose in The Lies of Locke Lamora

Scott Lynch’s prose is fluid and enjoyable. It creates an intelligent rhythm that keeps you alert. The writing is witty, subtle at times, and makes the world feel sharp and alive. The characters have distinct voices, and the gang shares a fantastic dynamic that feels authentic.

Jean Tannen is a legend. Bug is enthusiastic and full of fun. Their interactions often made me laugh and kept me hooked. Locke is one of my favourite fantasy characters. He isn’t a world-class fighter, but he is clever and daring. He reminded me of George Clooney in Ocean’s 11.

Readers who enjoy harsh, morally complex worlds should also check out The Blade Itself Book Review.

Review & Impressions

The mix of con men in a magical, alternate Venice immediately grabbed my attention. As a result, it made me fall in love with the story. This fantasy novel delivers snappy prose and a group of friends who are also criminal masterminds. They curse, face impossible odds, and still find moments of humor. Moreover, Scott Lynch keeps the story fresh with plot twists and believable worldbuilding.

The characters use modern swear words while staying witty, hilarious, and full of snarky conversations. The narrator feels clever and literary. It never becomes pulpy or cheap, and it always stays engaging. I felt amused, scared, and thrilled. Additionally, I enjoyed every detail while hunting for the truth.

The Gentleman Bastards are flawed, sometimes idiotic, yet easy to care for. Locke Lamora is my favorite, and each character feels interesting in their own way. My reviews are always spoiler-free, but this universe proves no one is safe. If you love heist movies, quick banter, strong worldbuilding, or a twist on old fantasy tropes, this book is perfect for you.

It became one of the highlights of my decade of reading fantasy novels. The second novel deepened that feeling. It even caused that post-book withdrawal where you wish you could forget everything and read it again for the first time.

Structure & Timelines

The novel uses simultaneous timelines that merge smoothly to show both the present and the past. Most of the story follows Locke in the present. The interludes from his childhood fill the gaps and add depth to his character. The shifting style is clear and strong, and it helps the story grow in surprising ways while keeping the character journey compelling.

Even though I am not usually a fan of multiple timelines, it worked beautifully here.

Final Rating on The Lies of Locke Lamora

The Lies of Locke Lamora is a great fantasy novel that ticks all the right boxes for me. The world feels fleshed out, the cast of characters is highly enjoyable, and the story keeps you fully engaged. What impressed me most was Lynch’s writing – it is truly engaging, with protagonists that show different levels of depth, making every reader feel invested in their journey.

I was genuinely excited to learn more as the book unfolded, especially about the trials, tribulations, and thievery of the Gentleman Bastards. In conclusion, many fans even call it one of the ultimate grimdark GOATs, and after reading it, I can clearly see why.

For another fantasy ruled by politics and betrayal, the A Game of Thrones Book Review fits perfectly.